
Robert Pogue Harrison's latest book is Gardens: an Essay on the Human Condition.
In the first chapter he looks at the garden as Paradise - the preserve of immortals - and guesses at what a cold pastoral it might be for humankind.
Menelaus, for example, was exempted from death and from Hades, and granted direct transport to Elysium, because, married to Helen, he was son-in-law to Zeus. The Trojan War was not fought over Helen as such, but the passport her bloodline provided to eternal bliss: 'men, Harrison observes, 'have gone to war for less compelling reasons.'
And yet, Harrison also observes, Menelaus tarries on earth, and is still there when Telemachus calls on him in The Odyssey.
To explain this, Harrison relates an ancient Latin parable of how Care, before crossing a river, fashioned a figure from clay. Jupiter, passing by, granted her wish to give it spirit, but wanted, also, the figure to bear his name. Earth arose and demanded it be named after her, as it was fashioned from her. The three asked Saturn to judge the matter. As Jupiter had endowed it with spirit, so, Saturn decided, the figure would belong to Jupiter after death. Earth, which had given it body, would give it a home, and Care, having fashioned it, would possess it while it lived. The figure was named homo, after humus (soil).
Harrison suggests that care - in several of its senses, and as both a burden and a virtue - is what animates us and makes us human. Menelaus might have had eternal bliss for the asking, but he resides on earth. The Dante of Il Paradiso remains as energised by earthly concerns as spiritual ones. On Calypso's Island, Ulysses still yearns for home, that lesser Heaven. Achilles in Hades is racked by envy of the living; he would rather be a slave under the sun (i.e. on earth) than king of all the perished dead.
Harrison notes how careless the Adam and Eve of Genesis are, how unthinkingly they fall - but the Fall is what makes them human. And, in Art, he makes us look again at how the expulsion was depicted. Regretting the loss of Eden, they still often seem to be rushing for the exit gate. For Harrison, felix culpa is a happy fall, not out of an Augustinian regard for Christ's then necessary sacrifice, but because it was the means by which we became human. 'It made life matter.' Condemned to cultivate the earth where once he was its honoured and passive guest, Adam begins the process by which we became cultivated.
Care engages and commits us...binds us so passionately to our living world... (and is) so tenacious as to continue to torment us after death... the everyday blessings we so sorely miss once we lose them.
In the second chapter, Harrison continues the theme and redeems the character of Eve: 'Eve's transgression was the first true instance of human action,' he claims. Eden's chill and static landscape cannot accommodate the human. 'For where there is no death, there is no birth either.' With rich quotations from Stevens, Neruda and, a favoured poet of Harrison's, Eleanor Wilner, Eve's fecundity is shown not simply to be her curse, but also our gift. The loss of Eden made us win other gardens of our own from the earth.

